My daughter, Natalie Suzanne (Pate) Mathews, 34, was shot and killed by her husband, Cecil Bradley Mathews, in their home in Orange Park, FL. on Monday, December 5, 2005. Cecil is serving a 25-year prison sentence for second-degree murder.
I have four reasons for writing this letter:
Firstly, I want Natalie’s friends to know what has happened since she was murdered. (The Pates have relatives in Crisp County and Ashburn).
Secondly, I want women and young girls who allow, justify and even defend their husbands or boyfriends who emotionally, mentally and/or physically abuse them, to pay careful attention to Natalie’s last words to me about her husband. Then give serious thought to their own situations.
Thirdly, I want the low-lifes who need to ‘prove their manhood’ by controlling and abusing ‘their’ women to remember this.
Apparently, Cecil Bradley Mathews, whose favorite TV program was CSI, thought he could outwit law enforcement officials, too. But Clay County Sheriff's investigators-- nailed him!
Because of their work, Mathews has a 25-year booking with Hotel Jackson C.I. in Florida. Unless, of course, he invokes the Interstate Compact and applies to serve his time in Oklahoma with a big Mack booking.
Natalie and Cecil were married on Nov. 30, 1996. Their daughter was born in Feb., 1997. Soon they also had a son.
Less than a month before the second baby was born, he either quit or was fired from his job, and from that point on, he was unable to keep a job.
On Nov. 9, 1998, three months after the birth of her son, Natalie went to the emergency room at Saint John's Hospital, Tulsa. She could barely breath. The next day, Natalie was diagnosed with a rare, terminal condition called fibrosing mediastinitis-- scar tissue growing inside the chest cavity.
She was, however, able to continue working, and she went into a management program with Cracker Barrel and did very well, but continued to have health problems.
In the Spring of 2005, Natalie told me she could no longer live with Cecil and wanted a divorce.
A few weeks later, however, she called again, and said she had been unable to make Cecil leave. She had promised the kids she would not divorce their daddy.
So she lived with a husband she no longer trusted.
She lived with a husband she no longer respected.
She lived with a husband she no longer loved.
Because of her health, she was unable to work the hours required for a general manager’s job which she was offered, and Cecil had been angry about her not taking the higher paying job, yet he had no job.
She continued to live with him because if she died suddenly, she wanted Cecil to be there to comfort the children. And she had made a promise to them.
Finally, she was fed up and told him she wanted a divorce which he agreed to this time, but she said she felt sorry for Cecil.
I told her, “If you’ve convinced him it’s really over between you, that he really has to leave, you need to be careful. He--Will--Hurt You.”
“Oh, Mom,” she said, “Cecil would never do anything to hurt me.”
Later that night, Natalie called 911 at 12:09 p.m. and told the dispatcher, “I’m dying.”
At 12:13 p.m. the dispatcher received another call from Natalie’s cell phone. This time the caller was Cecil.
He told the dispatcher that “his wife had just shot at him"; that "his wife had shot herself....”
Natalie was pronounced dead at 12:27 p.m.
Cecil was arrested and charged with second-degree murder. In April of 2006, a Clay County grand jury returned a first-degree murder indictment against him. The death penalty was now on the table. He pled guilty to the lesser charge on May 31 and was sentenced to 25 years in prison on June 15, 2006.
Finally, my most important reason for writing this letter.
It has taken me more than a year to be able to consistenly work on Natalie’s Hallmark Memory Book, a gift from my oldest daughter. As I was putting Natalie’s special things together--notes, letters, cards, awards, photos-- I began to realize that December 5 didn’t happen to just Natalie. It happened to all of us. For family and friends, especially Natalie’s children, it has affected our lives in ways which are unimaginable and indescribable. Nor did it happen to just Natalie and her family and friends. It happened to humanity as a whole.
By brutally destroying the life of my bright and beautiful young daughter, Cecil has deprived the world of that special light which glowed through Natalie’s warm and loving spirit. Through Cecil’s act of senseless violence, my grandchildren have joined the numberless ranks of helpless, suffering, voiceless children whose innocent young lives are shattered by the actions of careless, thoughtless adults--many of whom are their own parents.
My favorite lawman
In loving memory of Sheriff Donnie Haralson
August 11, 1955 - March 4, 2014
Our community mourned Friday as our greatest mentor and friend, Sheriff Donnie Haralson, was laid to rest after a lengthy and valiantly fought battle with cancer.
Letter to the Editor
I enjoy reminders of what I have: Freedom to be whomever I choose and to choose who leads me in government, abundance of good food, housing, transportation, and education opportunity, and above all others the freedom to worship as I believe and God’s grace in my Savior from sin.
God loves the hurt away
There are many things in life that we simply don’t understand.
Letter to the Editor
Cordele is probably not unique in that the story of our community has been told in the pages of a locally printed newspaper through the years.
While it seems that our rapidly changing technologies threaten the future of small towns, maybe even metropolitan areas, newspapers will be difficult for at least one more generation to find a substitute for local reporting.
One of God’s little lessons
NOTE: This was a little pre-New Year story that I shared with friends on facebook about a personal experience on New Year’s Eve. By request of several of those friends I decided to share it here for our readers who may not be on social media to enjoy.
From the time we are born until we die, our life is a series of milestones.
Apple pie has no place at Thanksgiving
It's practically a law that in late November, every publication must offer a Thanksgiving guide. This year, I would like to draw your attention to two exceptional ones.
Thank you for recycling
As the “15 Days of Recycling” continues, Keep Crisp Beautiful would like to thank you for helping and contributing to our event.
EDITORIALS: Move forward on immigration reform; SNAP cuts impact all
The chance of serious immigration reform passing in these closing weeks of Congress depends on how optimistic you are. / The 6 percent, or $5 billion, cut to the nation’s food stamp program will harm more than those individual recipients.
A bit more baseball
I never knew a baseball fan or player who didn’t want their favorite teams to win.
- More Opinion Headlines
- My favorite lawman